Loading...

European Innovation Scoreboard (EIS) 2024: Pathways to Innovation Excellence

Authors: Claudio Palmieri & Chiara Cremona

European Innovation Scoreboard (EIS) 2024

The European Commission has recently published the European Innovation Scoreboard (EIS), the annual report on the state of research and innovation in the European Union and individual Member States. The report also provides a comparison with neighboring European countries and some non-EU countries.

The EIS classifies Member States, based on their innovation scores, as:

  • Innovation leaders (innovation performance is above 125% of the EU average);
  • Strong innovators (between 100% and 125% of the EU average);
  • Moderate innovators (between 70% and 100% of the EU average);
  • Emerging innovators (below 70% of the EU average).

In general terms, the EIS 2024 shows that:

  • Italy is in the Moderate Innovators group, showing performance below the EU average, but is one of the fastest-growing countries in the EU (+10%).
  • Denmark remains the most innovative country in the EU;
  • Switzerland is the most innovative European country;
  • South Korea is the most innovative global competitor;
  • The European Union continues to improve its innovation performance at a steady pace, remains behind in terms of performance compared to South Korea, Canada, United States, Australia, and South Africa but has surpassed Japan since 2021;
  • China is reducing the gap with the EU.

Focus on Italy

Regarding Italy, the EIS lists:

Among the strengths:

  • Strong resource productivity
  • Strong increase in joint publications between public and private sectors
  • High percentage of SMEs introducing product innovations

Among the weaknesses:

  • A population with low tertiary education compared to the EU average
  • Low percentage of foreign doctoral students
  • Limited labor mobility of human resources in science and technology

Among significant performance increases since 2017:

  • A notable increase in collaborations between innovative SMEs
  • A significant increase in co-publications between public and private sectors
  • An increase in SMEs introducing business process innovations

Among significant reductions since 2017:

  • A reduction in the implementation of environmental technologies
  • A decrease in design applications
  • A decline in the percentage of foreign doctoral students

Among positive changes between 2023 and 2024:

  • An increase in process innovations in SMEs (+25.7%)
  • An increase in public-private shared publications (+22.6%)

Among negative changes between 2023 and 2024:

  • A decrease in environment-related technologies (-55.7%)
  • A decrease in design applications (-61.5%)

Focus on Successful Aspects of South Korea, Canada, United States, Australia, and South Africa Compared to the EU and Italy

The following list shows which aspects the EU and Italy should pay more attention to in competing with other countries to succeed in innovation.

2.1 High R&D Spending in the Private Sector and Business Investments in Innovation and Technological Development This factor seems to be among the most important in establishing leadership in innovation, considering that it is a key to success for South Korea and the United States and among the most important factors for countries such as Germany, Switzerland, and Denmark.

2.2 Government Support for R&D The United States, South Korea, Canada, Australia, and also France and Germany, have strong government support, both direct and indirect, for business R&D. This includes funding through grants, tax incentives, and other economic incentives that stimulate innovation, showing high levels of direct and indirect support for business R&D, suggesting government policies favorable to innovation.

2.3 Collaboration between SMEs and Innovation Australia, the United States, and Denmark show high levels of collaboration between SMEs and innovation, demonstrating a dynamic and cooperative entrepreneurial ecosystem.

2.4 Trademark and Patent Applications South Korea, the United States, Switzerland, and Germany have a high number of patent applications, indicating intense activity in intellectual property and protection of innovations.

2.5 High Level of Tertiary Education Canada, South Korea, and also Switzerland and Denmark, have a highly educated population, with a high percentage of graduates and doctorates, fundamental for a skilled workforce.

2.6 Internationalization of Research Australia and Canada, along with Switzerland and Denmark, excel in international scientific publications, highlighting strong collaboration and global visibility in research.

Conclusion

Among the key factors of success for the most innovative countries is an ecosystem with significant investments in innovation and research in the private sector, strong cooperation between companies, high internationalization capacity, strong ability to patent, and a high level of tertiary education. These factors are closely linked to the capacity of entrepreneurship in these countries as well as the ability of entrepreneurship to drive and attract a skilled workforce. From a public perspective, the keys to success for these countries are the ability to provide government support for R&D and innovation more generally.

Leave a Reply